Skip to main content

Head to head · Full-size pickups · 2021 · 2021 GMC Sierra 1500 vs 2021 Toyota Tundra

The first year of one V8's failure recall against the last year of another V8's run. The send-off wins the paper fight.

2021 is where the Sierra's engine story gets a headline: GM recalled roughly 597,000 trucks with the 6.2L V8 for connecting-rod and crankshaft defects, hitting Denali trims hardest. The 2021 Tundra is the last 5.7L V8 year with the smallest complaint file in its range — 23 complaints, three recalls, all free.

506 vs 23 federal complaints · 7 vs 3 recalls · 2 full reports with mechanic & forum testimony

The board

Numbers from each year’s full report
Canary status: Squawking

2021 GMC Sierra 1500

Watch the engine — first year of the big 6.2L failure recall, which hits Denali trims hardest.

506

Federal complaints

7

Recall campaigns

$0

6.2L V8 under recall 25V274 — inspect, repair, or replace

Canary status: Calm

2021 Toyota Tundra

The last 5.7L V8 Tundra and the smallest complaint file in the range — the send-off year, worth buying for the engine everyone misses.

23

Federal complaints

3

Recall campaigns

$0

Power-steering gear replacement under recall 21V-920

Both headline risks are free fixes — the difference is that the Sierra's sits on a brand-new campaign and the Tundra's closes out a settled file.

See where both rank among Full-size pickups

Where each one bites

The signature problems, with real repair money — every fact cited in the full reports.

2021 Sierra 1500

6.2L V8 connecting-rod / crankshaft failure — recall 25V274

Covered

The defining 2021 issue if the truck has the 6.2L — and the Sierra Denali, which skews to that engine, is disproportionately affected. GM recalled about 597,571 vehicles (2021–2024 Sierra, Silverado, Tahoe, Yukon, Escalade) for connecting-rod and crankshaft defects that put debris in the oil and can cause sudden engine failure — 'no warning, just died' — with NHTSA expanding its probe twice. GM estimates roughly a 3% defect rate; the remedy inspects and repairs or replaces the engine free and moves to 0W-40 oil. A used 6.2L that's been through the recall is a known quantity; one that hasn't is an open question. Confirm completion by VIN.

Sources: NHTSA complaint database, 2021 Sierra 1500 · NHTSA recall database and manufacturer communications (recall 25V274; transmission-valve coverage; eBoost CSP)

5.3L Dynamic Fuel Management (DFM) lifter failure

$3,000–$10,000

If it's the 5.3L, the lifter issue rides on. DFM can deactivate any of all eight cylinders, and mechanics say its lifters fail more often and earlier than the older AFM — a tick, misfire, power loss, and a $3,000–$10,000 repair with no recall, only a class action and reactive warranty repairs. A DFM disabler (~$150) is cheap prevention and a cold-start tick is the walk-away sign. The 6.2L's risk is largely covered by its recall while the 5.3L's lifter risk is not — factor that into which one you buy.

Sources: NHTSA complaint database, 2021 Sierra 1500 · Independent mechanic transcripts (T1XX Silverado/Sierra; AFM/DFM lifter deep-dives)

8-speed transmission — costliest failure is covered

Covered

The 8-speed can still shudder and shift harshly, but the expensive control-valve failure is covered on this year by GM's 15-year/150,000-mile Special Coverage (from the in-service date, regardless of ownership) — a new valve body free, with reimbursement for prior repairs. The 10-speed on other trims is the stronger unit. Test-drive for shudder and confirm the coverage window. There is a second 2021 transmission program worth checking alongside it: a Customer Satisfaction Program for trucks with the 8-speed (GM's option code MQE) that “may have a broken reaction carrier in the transmission,” where the remedy is to replace the transmission. It is the first federal document tying a 2021 truck's 8-speed to a full replacement rather than a valve body or a fluid change — VIN-check it as well as the control-valve coverage.

Sources: NHTSA recall database and manufacturer communications (recall 25V274; transmission-valve coverage; eBoost CSP) · Independent mechanic transcripts (T1XX Silverado/Sierra; AFM/DFM lifter deep-dives)

2021 Tundra

Power-steering gear can fail — recall 21V-920 (free)

Covered

Recall 21V-920 (Toyota 21TB10/21TA10) covers the 2007–2021 Tundra power-steering gear, which can be manufactured incorrectly, leak, and cause a sudden loss of assist; the companion 21E-103 (21TH01) covers the service parts. Both are free inspect/replace. One 2021 owner whose power steering failed around 38,000 miles was quoted over $6,000 for the assembly out of scope and noted 'they recalled a significant portion of the vehicles made in 2021' — which is exactly why you confirm the free repair shows completed by VIN.

Sources: NHTSA complaint + recall database, 2021 Tundra · NHTSA recalls and manufacturer communications (recall documents, Toyota internal codes)

Headlight circuit fire risk — recall 21V-688

Covered

Recall 21V-688 (Toyota 21TB06/21TA06) covers 2018–2021 Tundra: the headlight electrical circuit may power the high and low beams at the same time and overheat the connector, which can start a fire. Dealers modify the engine wire harness and replace any damaged bulb, connector, or headlight assembly, free. Verify by VIN — several owners noted the recall part was on backorder for a time.

Sources: NHTSA complaint + recall database, 2021 Tundra · NHTSA recalls and manufacturer communications (recall documents, Toyota internal codes)

Combination-meter LCD blank, seat play, and other characteristics

minor

The remaining 2021 reports are low-frequency characteristics, not failures. The combination-meter (instrument LCD) can go blank — an owner asked to be included in the 2022–2023 recall (23V-111) that covers exactly this display; check whether a fix was applied. Several owners describe the driver's seat rocking back and forth under braking or acceleration (dealers cite the seat track). Others note sunroof shatter, a front-end shimmy, windshield fragility, and TRD Pro accessory LED-light rattle. None are dealbreakers, but they shape the test drive.

Sources: NHTSA complaint + recall database, 2021 Tundra

The tiebreakers

How to actually decide, listing by listing.

Send-off versus campaign

  1. A 6.2L Sierra only with 25V274 resolved on the VIN.

    The connecting-rod recall is inspect-repair-or-replace at no cost, and it's the whole ballgame on this year. A Denali with the recall open is a truck you're test-driving for GM.

  2. A 5.3L Sierra trades the headline for the lottery.

    The smaller V8 dodges 25V274 but keeps the DFM lifter risk — $3,000–$10,000 after failure, no recall, ~$150 for the preventive disabler. The 8-speed's costliest failure stays covered to 15 years/150k either way.

  3. Tundra: verify 21V-920, then inspect for age.

    The steering-gear recall replacement is free. After that the checks are the cam-tower reseal ($1,200–$1,500 when it weeps) and, in salt states, the frame — the two taxes on a design that otherwise just runs.

  4. The Sierra's free-program stack is deeper than it looks.

    Water-pump circuit board and eBoost brake CSPs, the evaporative-purge Special Coverage, and the transmission control-valve coverage all ride the VIN. A Sierra with every program documented is a materially better buy than the same truck without.

Not set on 2021?

The matchup flips by year. Pick a different pair of cells and the verdict changes.

One year back softens both stories: the 2020 Sierra is Chirping at 434 with the control-valve coverage behind it, and the 2020 Tundra is Calm at 45. Forward, the 2022 Tundra Squawks at 415 with the twin-turbo debris recall — the V8 ends at 2021.

Compare any two

Any two years, side by side — the numbers line up even before we’ve written the verdict. We line up years of the same model, or two rivals from the same segment in the same year.

First vehicle
Second vehicle
One V8 just entered its recall era; the other just finished its run without one that costs you money.
The 2021 V8 crossroads

Found one of each? Let the canary referee.

Paste either VIN and we’ll check its open recalls, campaign status, and build date against everything in these two reports — free.

Check a VIN — free