Skip to main content

Head to head · Full-size pickups · 2021 · 2021 Ram 1500 vs 2021 Toyota Tundra

The modern truck's engine is the story. The old truck's engine is the reason to buy it.

By 2021 the Ram is polished everywhere except the place that matters: its file is led by cracked Hemi exhaust manifolds, eTorque failures, and a cam-and-lifter tick that quotes from about $4,500. The 2021 Tundra is the last 5.7L V8 year and the smallest complaint file in its entire range — 23 complaints, three recalls, all free.

653 vs 23 federal complaints · 14 vs 3 recalls · 2 full reports with mechanic & forum testimony

The board

Numbers from each year’s full report
Canary status: Squawking

2021 Ram 1500

A mature, well-sorted truck on paper — but 2021 is where the engine becomes the story: Hemi manifold bolts, lifter tick, and eTorque failures.

653

Federal complaints

14

Recall campaigns

~$4,500

Hemi cam-and-lifter repair — mechanic-quoted minimum

Canary status: Calm

2021 Toyota Tundra

The last 5.7L V8 Tundra and the smallest complaint file in the range — the send-off year, worth buying for the engine everyone misses.

23

Federal complaints

3

Recall campaigns

$0

Power-steering gear replacement under recall 21V-920

One file is an engine story with owner-paid endings; the other is a send-off year buyers seek out on purpose.

See where both rank among Full-size pickups

Where each one bites

The signature problems, with real repair money — every fact cited in the full reports.

2021 1500

5.7L Hemi exhaust manifold bolts / cracked manifolds

major

The loudest 2021 complaint. The 5.7 Hemi's exhaust-manifold bolts snap and the manifolds crack — owners report a tick that grows louder over time and, in the worst cases, exhaust fumes leaking into the cab, with dealers acknowledging it as a known issue. It's a leak repair that gets more involved (and more expensive) the longer it's left. On the test drive, cold-start and listen for a tick that's loudest when the engine is cold and eases as it warms — the classic manifold-leak signature — distinct from the deeper valvetrain lifter tick.

Sources: NHTSA complaint database, 2021 Ram 1500 · Independent mechanic channel transcripts (5.7 Hemi manifold/cam/lifter; eTorque MGU teardown)

eTorque 48-volt motor-generator (MGU) failure

~$5,000

On eTorque trucks, the 48-volt mild-hybrid runs off a belt-driven motor-generator unit that independent mechanics call 'notoriously known for going bad' — essentially a complex alternator-plus-motor that stop/start duty wears hard. Owners report the dealer condemning the eTorque and advising against driving. Repair costs vary widely by shop: one mechanic recounts a job another shop quoted around $5,000 (nearly totaling the truck) that an independent did for under $1,000. A separate PCM recall (23V265) covers a 5.7 eTorque fuel-mixture fault that can stall the engine. A non-eTorque Hemi or the Pentastar V6 avoids this system entirely.

Sources: NHTSA complaint database, 2021 Ram 1500 · NHTSA recall database and manufacturer communications (recall 23V265; CSN W82; camera/airbag recalls) · Independent mechanic channel transcripts (5.7 Hemi manifold/cam/lifter; eTorque MGU teardown)

5.7L Hemi cam-and-lifter tick

higher

The Hemi's valvetrain risk runs alongside the manifold issue: a worn hydraulic lifter and cam lobe tick and eventually misfire, sometimes with low oil pressure and, in the worst reports, catastrophic engine failure. Independent mechanics quote a cam-and-lifter repair at a minimum around $4,500, with engine replacement often recommended once metal shows in the oil. The recent file also carries oil-pan corrosion and stall-with-no-warning reports. Cold-start and listen for a deep valvetrain tick separate from the manifold leak.

Sources: NHTSA complaint database, 2021 Ram 1500 · Independent mechanic channel transcripts (5.7 Hemi manifold/cam/lifter; eTorque MGU teardown)

2021 Tundra

Power-steering gear can fail — recall 21V-920 (free)

Covered

Recall 21V-920 (Toyota 21TB10/21TA10) covers the 2007–2021 Tundra power-steering gear, which can be manufactured incorrectly, leak, and cause a sudden loss of assist; the companion 21E-103 (21TH01) covers the service parts. Both are free inspect/replace. One 2021 owner whose power steering failed around 38,000 miles was quoted over $6,000 for the assembly out of scope and noted 'they recalled a significant portion of the vehicles made in 2021' — which is exactly why you confirm the free repair shows completed by VIN.

Sources: NHTSA complaint + recall database, 2021 Tundra · NHTSA recalls and manufacturer communications (recall documents, Toyota internal codes)

Headlight circuit fire risk — recall 21V-688

Covered

Recall 21V-688 (Toyota 21TB06/21TA06) covers 2018–2021 Tundra: the headlight electrical circuit may power the high and low beams at the same time and overheat the connector, which can start a fire. Dealers modify the engine wire harness and replace any damaged bulb, connector, or headlight assembly, free. Verify by VIN — several owners noted the recall part was on backorder for a time.

Sources: NHTSA complaint + recall database, 2021 Tundra · NHTSA recalls and manufacturer communications (recall documents, Toyota internal codes)

Combination-meter LCD blank, seat play, and other characteristics

minor

The remaining 2021 reports are low-frequency characteristics, not failures. The combination-meter (instrument LCD) can go blank — an owner asked to be included in the 2022–2023 recall (23V-111) that covers exactly this display; check whether a fix was applied. Several owners describe the driver's seat rocking back and forth under braking or acceleration (dealers cite the seat track). Others note sunroof shatter, a front-end shimmy, windshield fragility, and TRD Pro accessory LED-light rattle. None are dealbreakers, but they shape the test drive.

Sources: NHTSA complaint + recall database, 2021 Tundra

The tiebreakers

How to actually decide, listing by listing.

The V8 tiebreak

  1. Tundra first — but verify 21V-920 on the VIN.

    The power-steering-gear recall is the one open item with teeth on this year, and the recall replacement is free. Confirm it shows closed before the test drive, not after.

  2. The Tundra's tax is age, not design.

    The cam-tower oil reseal runs $1,200–$1,500 when it weeps, and in salt states the frame inspection comes before falling in love — a frame replacement costs more than the truck is worth.

  3. A Ram only after the engine interview.

    Cold-start manifold tick, eTorque behavior at stop-start, and any lifter tick are the three listens. The cam-and-lifter job quotes from about $4,500 and mechanics often recommend full engine replacement — price either into the offer or walk.

  4. eTorque cuts both ways — get the software recall closed.

    Independent shops have repaired the 48-volt system for under $1,000 where dealers quoted several times that, and the 23V265 stall-risk software fix is free. A Ram with both handled is a much stronger candidate.

Not set on 2021?

The matchup flips by year. Pick a different pair of cells and the verdict changes.

The swap only helps on one side: a 2020 Ram is Chirping at 605 complaints, while the 2022 Tundra jumps to Squawking at 415 with the twin-turbo debris recall — the V8 ends here.

Compare any two

Any two years, side by side — the numbers line up even before we’ve written the verdict. We line up years of the same model, or two rivals from the same segment in the same year.

First vehicle
Second vehicle
The smallest complaint file in the range, wearing the engine everyone misses.
The 2021 Tundra, closing its own argument

Found one of each? Let the canary referee.

Paste either VIN and we’ll check its open recalls, campaign status, and build date against everything in these two reports — free.

Check a VIN — free