VinCanary

Reliability report · 2017 Subaru Forester · Updated July 2026

The busiest fourth-gen year on complaints, but the pattern is the familiar cam-carrier oil leak — inspect the engine and you're buying a solid Forester.

The 2017 carries the fourth-generation Forester's core trait: the FB25 boxer's cam-carrier oil leak, which reseals for roughly the cost of a used transmission because the seam is sealed with RTV silicone rather than a gasket. A cluster of owners also report burning oil and, in a few cases, engine noise or a failed catalytic converter. None of it is covered by a factory program.

The reassuring part: only one recall touches the 2017 — the passenger-airbag occupant-sensor connector (19V701), a free fix. And the oil-consumption warranty program everyone associates with Subaru does not apply here; it ends at the 2015 model year. Inspect the engine for seepage, confirm the recall, and this is a dependable buy.

Evidence: 578 NHTSA complaints · 1 recall campaigns · 4 mechanic & forum sources

Canary status

Chirping

What that means: 578 federal complaints — the most of any fourth-gen year here — but the engine cluster is the same cam-carrier oil leak and a handful of oil-consumption reports, not a new failure. Only one recall applies, and it's free.

CalmChirpingSquawkingFainted

578

Federal complaints

1

Recall

~$3,800

Cam-carrier reseal (owner-reported, 2016 sibling)

Known issues

Ranked by the cost of ignoring them. Every claim carries its source.

Cam-carrier oil leak — the fourth-gen signature

major

As on the 2016, the FB25 boxer's cam carrier is sealed to the head with RTV silicone, and that seam eventually seeps oil onto a hot exhaust manifold — owners smell burnt oil and see it weeping down the engine. It's the same pattern as the mechanically related fifth-generation Outback, and it's the one repair here with no extended coverage. Inspect for oil on the sides of the engine and a hot-oil smell before buying; keeping the PCV system healthy and oil changes on time slows it, but age eventually wins.

What to check

Pink and cleanServiced. Proceed.

Dark brownDamage underway.

Cam-carrier reseal (owner-reported, 2016 sibling)

~$3,800

Sources: NHTSA complaint database, 2017 Subaru Forester (true count 578) · Independent Subaru mechanic + owner channel transcripts (cam-carrier leak, oil-consumption teardown)

Oil consumption — not the covered programmoderate

The 2017 complaint file includes blunt oil-burning reports — one owner wrote simply 'need new engine keeps burning oil.' Important context: Subaru's oil-consumption warranty extension (8 years/100,000 miles), its piston-ring surface-treatment fix, and the class-action settlement all cover 2011–2015 engines only and do NOT reach 2017. A same-era 2017 XT owner separately reported burning no measurable oil at 10,000 miles, so this is a car-by-car condition question, not a blanket defect. Check oil level on the dipstick at the viewing, ask for oil-change records, and if it's a heavy drinker, walk — there's no program to fall back on.

Sources: NHTSA complaint database, 2017 Subaru Forester (true count 578) · Independent Subaru mechanic + owner channel transcripts (cam-carrier leak, oil-consumption teardown)

Passenger-airbag occupant-sensor recall — freemoderate

Recall 19V701 (WUM-98) covers 2015–2018 Foresters with heated seats: the passenger seat's Occupant Detection System (ODS — the sensor that decides whether the passenger airbag arms) connection can loosen and deactivate the passenger airbag even when the seat is occupied. Dealers inspect and replace the sensor-mat harness free. This is the only recall on the 2017 — confirm it's closed by VIN.

Sources: NHTSA recalls + manufacturer communications (19V701; front-exhaust and battery-drain extensions; oil-consumption program scope)

$0

ODS harness inspect/replace (recall)

Front exhaust rattle — covered by an extensionminor

Some owners hear a rattle or flutter from the undercarriage during acceleration. Subaru issued a warranty extension and a redesigned front exhaust pipe and covers for 2017–2018 Foresters to address it. If you hear an intermittent metallic rattle under load, this is the likely source and it may be covered — ask the dealer about the front-exhaust-pipe extension.

Sources: NHTSA recalls + manufacturer communications (19V701; front-exhaust and battery-drain extensions; oil-consumption program scope)

Battery drain — covered by a class-action extensionminor

Repeated dead 12-volt batteries show up across these years. Subaru's battery-drain class-action settlement extended 12-volt coverage for 2015–2020 vehicles. A history of jump-starts on a 2017 usually traces here — confirm the extension work and whether the parasitic-drain fix was applied, not just fresh batteries.

Sources: NHTSA complaint database, 2017 Subaru Forester (true count 578) · NHTSA recalls + manufacturer communications (19V701; front-exhaust and battery-drain extensions; oil-consumption program scope)

need new engine keeps burning oil
4 mechanic & owner sources

Shopping this year?

Get the printable pre-purchase checklist and an alert if this year’s recall sheet changes.

Open recalls

Free fixes at any Subaru dealer. Run the VIN — “completed” isn’t always completed.

  1. 19V701Passenger-seat Occupant Detection System connector may loosen and deactivate the passenger airbag (2015–2018 Forester with heated seats). Free inspect/replace of the ODS sensor-mat harness. Subaru code WUM-98.open

Have a specific one in your sights?

The VIN is on the listing. We’ll check this exact car — build, open recalls, and whether the “completed” repairs stayed fixed.