VinCanary

Reliability report · 2016 Ford Explorer · Updated July 2026

A fifth-generation Explorer with an expensive engine-and-driveline to-do list — buyable only with the water-pump, PTU, and recall history in hand.

The 2016 is a fifth-generation Explorer, and its defining problems are mechanical: on the 3.5L V6 the water pump is driven by the timing chain and buried behind it, so when it fails it can push coolant into the oil (a 'milky dipstick') and, left unchecked, blow the engine — and the fix is effectively a timing-chain job. On all-wheel-drive cars the Power Transfer Unit (PTU) leaks oil from its seal at low mileage; one shop said it has 'replaced over 20 of them.'

On top of the mechanical list sits a wall of recalls — the rear suspension toe-link that fractures in salt states, and A-pillar and B-pillar trim that detaches while driving, both of which owners report waiting a year-plus for parts. Ford runs a Customer Support Program for the gen-5 carbon-monoxide/exhaust-odor concern (19N05) and an extended transmission program for 2.3L cars, but the water pump and PTU are on you. This is a buyable truck only with the maintenance records and recall status verified.

Evidence: 2,423 NHTSA complaints · 14 recall campaigns · 6 mechanic & forum sources

Canary status

Squawking

What that means: 2,423 federal complaints — the loudest year in our Explorer data. The expensive patterns are the timing-chain-driven water pump on the 3.5L V6, the leaking Power Transfer Unit on all-wheel-drive cars, and an aging six-speed. Ford has quiet programs for the exhaust-in-cabin concern and the transmission, but the mechanical failures fall on the owner.

CalmChirpingSquawkingFainted

This status assumes the riskiest common powertrain — see the Explorer engine guide.

2,423

Federal complaints

14

Recalls

several thousand, directional

Timing-chain + water-pump job (parts + labor)

Known issues

Ranked by the cost of ignoring them. Every claim carries its source.

3.5L V6 internal water pump — the timing-chain-driven failure

major
  • 3.5L Ti-VCT V6

On the 3.5L V6, the water pump is driven by the timing chain and lives behind it. An independent teardown mechanic is blunt: 'the water pump is run by the timing chain, and when they go you might as well do the timing chain, the water pump, the whole nine yards.' When the pump seeps internally, coolant mixes with the oil — owners describe a 'milky' dipstick — and chronic coolant loss can crack a cylinder or destroy the engine with little warning. The 2017-adjacent complaint file (same engine family) is full of it: 'coolant into the oil, blew my engine,' water pumps replaced twice in a year. Because the pump is behind the timing cover, the labor is the expensive part. On any 3.5L, check the dipstick for milkiness, look for unexplained coolant loss, and treat a documented water-pump-plus-timing-chain job as a plus, not a red flag.

What to check

Pink and cleanServiced. Proceed.

Dark brownDamage underway.

This is a 3.5L Ti-VCT V6 problem. The 3.5L EcoBoost V6, 2.3L EcoBoost I4, 2.7L EcoBoost V6, and 3.0L EcoBoost V6 don’t share it.

Which engine is in the one you found? →

Timing-chain + water-pump job (parts + labor)

several thousand, directional

Sources: NHTSA complaint database, 2016 Ford Explorer · NHTSA manufacturer communications (CSP 19N05 carbon monoxide, 20N07/20B27 transmission) + independent gen-5 Explorer mechanic transcripts

Power Transfer Unit (PTU) oil leak — plan for it on AWD carsmajor

  • 3.5L Ti-VCT V6
  • 2.3L EcoBoost I4

On all-wheel-drive cars the Power Transfer Unit — the gearbox that sends power to the rear axle, sitting beneath the exhaust — leaks oil from its pinion seal at low mileage. A gen-5 shop mechanic: 'I probably replaced over 20 PTUs; they all pretty much leak.' The fluid is sealed for life from the factory, so once it starts leaking the fluid overheats, vents, and the unit fails internally; the fix is roughly six hours of labor. The prevention mechanics recommend is changing that sealed fluid every 15,000-20,000 miles with a new drain plug. On an AWD 2016, look underneath for oil weeping around the PTU and ask whether the fluid has ever been serviced.

Sources: NHTSA complaint database, 2016 Ford Explorer · NHTSA manufacturer communications (CSP 19N05 carbon monoxide, 20N07/20B27 transmission) + independent gen-5 Explorer mechanic transcripts

a few hundred

PTU fluid service (preventive)

$1,000+, directional

PTU replacement (≈6 hrs labor)

Exhaust fumes into the cabin — Customer Support Program 19N05moderate

The gen-5 Explorer's best-known concern is exhaust odor — sometimes measurable carbon monoxide — reaching the cabin. A mechanic explains that in cases with no oil leak, 'the exhaust fumes from the rear exhaust get inside the cabin.' Ford created a CSP — a Customer Support Program, the industry's quiet extended-coverage — numbered 19N05, covering 2011-2017 Explorers for this concern. If you smell exhaust inside, especially with the climate system on recirculate-off and the tailgate area, ask whether 19N05 work was performed and verify the exact coverage terms in the bulletin.

Sources: NHTSA complaint database, 2016 Ford Explorer · NHTSA manufacturer communications (CSP 19N05 carbon monoxide, 20N07/20B27 transmission) + independent gen-5 Explorer mechanic transcripts

$0

Under CSP 19N05

Six-speed transmission — slipping, harsh shifts, and a program for 2.3L carsmoderate

  • 2.3L EcoBoost I4

The gen-5 automatic draws complaints of harsh jolts, slipping, and 'won't go into drive.' Ford runs Customer Support Program 20N07/20B27 for 2016-2019 Explorers with the 2.3L engine, extending transmission coverage and adding a powertrain-control-module reflash for the torque converter — with a further 12-month torque-converter warranty from the date of that reflash. On the V6 cars the coverage is thinner. On a test drive, feel for slip or a shudder that a dealer reflash can't cure, and on a 2.3L car ask whether the 20N07/20B27 work was done.

Sources: NHTSA complaint database, 2016 Ford Explorer · NHTSA manufacturer communications (CSP 19N05 carbon monoxide, 20N07/20B27 transmission) + independent gen-5 Explorer mechanic transcripts

$0

Under CSP 20N07/20B27 (2.3L)

Rear toe-link fracture and detaching pillar trim — the recall stackmoderate

Two safety recalls dominate the recent complaint sample. The rear suspension toe link can corrode and fracture in road-salt states — a loss-of-control risk — under a chain of expanding recalls (19V-435, then 20V-675 and 21V-537 for salt-belt cars). And the A-pillar trim (24V-031) and B-pillar door trim (25V-347) can detach while driving; the recent complaint file is full of owners who report the trim flying off at highway speed and then waiting a year or more for parts. All are free repairs — the catch is availability. Verify by VIN which are open and whether parts have arrived.

Sources: NHTSA complaint database, 2016 Ford Explorer · NHTSA recall database, 2016 Ford Explorer

$0

Recall repairs (toe link, A/B-pillar trim)

The internal water pump on my 3.5L failed — coolant went into the oil and blew my engine, with no warning.
6 mechanic & owner sources

Shopping this year?

Get the printable pre-purchase checklist and an alert if this year’s recall sheet changes.

Open recalls

Free fixes at any Ford dealer. Run the VIN — “completed” isn’t always completed.

  1. 19V-435Rear suspension toe links may fracture, causing a sudden change in handling. Free toe-link replacement and ball-joint inspection (2011-2017). Ford number 19S17.open
  2. 21V-537Salt-belt expansion: cross-axis ball joint can corrode and seize, fracturing the rear toe link. Free CABJ/toe-link repair (2013-2017 salt states; expands 16V-245/19V-435/20V-675). Ford number 21S32.open
  3. 20V-692Front drive-axle halfshaft support bracket may fail, causing loss of park function or loss of motive power. Free link-shaft bracket replacement (2.0L/2.3L FWD). Ford number 20S63.open
  4. 16V-1832.3L GTDI engine block heater elements may overheat while plugged in, a fire risk. Free block-heater replacement (2016). Ford number 16S14.open
  5. 24V-031A-pillar trim retention clips may not engage, letting the trim detach and become a road hazard. Free inspection/replacement (2011-2019). Ford number 24S02.open
  6. 25V-347Driver and front-passenger B-pillar door trim may detach while driving. Repair free of charge; remedy still under development in 2025 (2016-2017). Ford number 25S53.open
  7. 16V-475Manual-recline driver's seat back frame may have insufficient welds (FMVSS 202/207). Free inspection/replacement (2016 Explorer and F-150). Ford number 16C11.open
  8. 25V-685Engine block heater may crack, leak coolant, and short-circuit when plugged in — a fire risk. Free block-heater replacement or blanking-plug option (2016-2023). Ford number 25SA4.open

Have a specific one in your sights?

The VIN is on the listing. We’ll check this exact car — build, open recalls, and whether the “completed” repairs stayed fixed.